CSV vs JSON vs Excel — How to Choose the Right Format & What to Consider When Preparing Each File (A Practical Guide for Developers & Analysts)

https://www.youtube.com/@DotNetFullstackDev

Today every project — whether it’s a .NET system, a BI pipeline, an ETL workflow, or a simple reporting job — eventually asks the same question:

“Should I output this data as CSV, JSON, or Excel?”

At first, it feels simple.
But when you start preparing the actual files, suddenly:

• Your CSV breaks because someone typed a comma inside a comment

• Your JSON fails because of a missing bracket

• Your Excel file becomes 45MB and refuses to open on someone’s laptop

• Your API consumer says “we need nested objects, not flat data”

• Your business stakeholder says “add colors and formulas inside Excel”

This blog will remove all that confusion.

Let’s break down the key differentiating factors, real-time use cases, and best practices for preparing CSV, JSON, and Excel — the three most used data formats in the world.

---

First Step: Understand What These File Formats Actually Represent

Before comparing, understand the nature of the formats.

CSV = Flat data

• Rows + columns

• No hierarchy

• Good for large datasets

• Very lightweight

• Supported everywhere

JSON = Structured + hierarchical data

• Perfect for APIs

• Supports nested objects, arrays

• Human + machine friendly

• Ideal for configuration or complex data structures

Excel = Rich data container

• Tables

• Formatting

• Charts

• Formulas

• Multiple sheets

• Business-friendly

Think of it like this:

FormatReal-world analogyCSVA notebook with only lines — pure raw dataJSONA container with sections, boxes, and labelsExcelA decorated project file with charts, colors, and formulas

Now let’s go deeper.

---

When Preparing CSV Files — Key Things to Consider

CSV is deceptively simple.

But preparing a CSV correctly requires precision, otherwise one wrong comma breaks the entire dataset.

1. Always define your delimiter (comma, semicolon, tab)

Default is comma (,).
But sometimes fields themselves contain commas:

“John, Alex”, 29, “India”

If you do not quote such fields, your CSV becomes invalid.

Many European countries prefer semicolon (;) because comma is used as a decimal separator.

2. Escape or quote values that contain special characters

Special characters include:

• commas

• newlines

• tabs

• quotes

Follow correct quoting:

“Hello, World”
“This is a “”quoted”“ value”
“Line1
Line2”

3. Keep column order consistent

Never reorder columns between exports unless absolutely necessary.

Systems downstream may break.

4. Avoid merging data types in the same column

Bad:

Name, Value
Age, 30
Price, $15

Good:

FieldName, FieldValue, FieldType
Age, 30, Integer
Price, 15, Currency

5. Avoid leading zeros if values represent IDs

Excel automatically removes leading zeros (e.g., 00123 → 123).

Workaround:

• Quote them “00123”

• Prepend ‘ (apostrophe)

6. Choose UTF-8 encoding

Prevent issues with:

• special characters

• Indian regional languages

• emojis

• accented names

7. Don’t include formulas

CSV is flat text.
No formulas, no formatting.
If you need formulas → Excel.

---

When Preparing JSON Files — Key Things to Consider

JSON supports complex, deeply nested structures.

But that power brings its own challenges.

1. Valid JSON structure is mandatory

One missing } will break everything.

Use online validators or automated serializers.

2. Be careful with data types

JSON allows:

• numbers

• strings

• arrays

• objects

• booleans

• null

All numbers default to float / double type — watch out for precision (especially with money).

3. Decide between compact vs pretty JSON

Compact:

{”user”:”John”,”age”:29}

Pretty formatted:

{
  “user”: “John”,
  “age”: 29
}

Pretty printing is good for humans;
compact is good for APIs and file transfer.

✔ 4. Use consistent naming style

• camelCase

• PascalCase

• snake_case

Example:

{
  “firstName”: “John”,
  “lastName”: “Alex”
}

5. Keep boolean values boolean, not strings

Bad:

“isActive”: “true”

Good:

“isActive”: true

6. Large JSON → consider splitting

If your JSON is larger than 5MB:

• Break into smaller JSON lines → NDJSON (“newline delimited JSON”)

• Use streaming serializers

7. JSON doesn’t support comments

Never write:

{
   // this is a comment
}

It breaks parsing.

---

When Preparing Excel Files — Key Things to Consider

Excel is powerful, but tricky.

It’s the only format that business teams often request because:

• They want filters

• They want pivot tables

• They want colors

• They want formulas

• They want multiple sheets

But as a developer, Excel is the easiest format to accidentally misuse.

1. Avoid more than 1 million rows

Excel’s row limit is:

• 1,048,576 rows

• 16,384 columns

If you exceed → use CSV instead.

2. Avoid embedding large images inside sheets

This increases file size like crazy.

3. Prefer simple formats rather than heavy styling

Excessive styling = slow opening.

4. If your Excel will be consumed by a program, avoid:

• merged cells

• formulas

• conditional formatting

• hidden rows

• auto filters

These break automated parsing.

5. If you DO need formulas — place them carefully

Example:

=SUM(A2:A100)
=IF(B2>10, “High”,”Low”)

Always document formulas in a separate sheet.

6. Use freeze panes for readability

Useful for files that business teams use.

7. Use Excel libraries correctly in .NET

Recommended libraries:

• EPPlus

• ClosedXML

• NPOI

Each has pros and cons depending on file size & complexity.

8. Watch out for Excel’s weird auto-conversion

Excel converts:

• “1-2” into a date

• “0012” into “12”

• “TRUE” into boolean

• “1.5E5” into exponential

• long numbers like credit-card digits into scientific notation

If the content is sensitive → store as text intentionally.

Keep the Momentum Going — Support the Journey

If this post helped you level up or added value to your day, feel free to fuel the next one — Buy Me a Coffee powers deeper breakdowns, real-world examples, and crisp technical storytelling.

---

Final Comparison — Choosing the Right Format (Simple Mental Model)

✔ Choose CSV when:

• You have large or flat data

• You don’t need formatting

• You want fastest export & import

• You want lightweight & universal

✔ Choose JSON when:

• You need nested structure

• You are interacting with APIs

• You need config files or metadata

• You need both human & machine readability

✔ Choose Excel when:

• Business users are the target

• You need formulas/charts

• You need multiple sheets

• You want filters, pivots, styling

---

The Ultimate One-Line Rules

CSV:

Use when speed matters. Flat data only.

JSON:

Use when structure matters. Machines + APIs.

Excel:

Use when humans matter. Reporting + visualization.

---

Closing Note

Choosing the right file format is a subtle but crucial decision in every project.
Knowing the strengths, limits, and preparation rules of CSV, JSON, and Excel makes you a better developer — especially in backend, ETL, reporting, or API design.